Die Ruinen von Athen, Op.113 (Beethoven, Ludwig van)

Movements/SectionsMov'ts/Sec's 9 sections
Composition Year 1811 (and 1822)
Genre Categories Incidental music; Theatrical Works; For 3 voices, mixed chorus, orchestra; [26 more...]For voices and chorus with orchestra; Scores featuring the voice; Scores featuring the soprano voice; Scores featuring the bass voice; Scores featuring mixed chorus; Scores featuring the orchestra; German language; For 2 pianos (arr); Scores featuring the piano (arr); For 2 players (arr); For orchestra (arr); Scores featuring the orchestra (arr); For 2 pianos 8 hands (arr); For 4 players (arr); For piano 4 hands (arr); Scores featuring the piano 4 hands (arr); For piano (arr); For 1 player (arr); For violin, piano (arr); Scores featuring the violin (arr); For wind band (arr); For orchestra without strings (arr); Scores featuring wind band (arr); For 2 violins, viola, cello (arr); Scores featuring the viola (arr); Scores featuring the cello (arr)
Related Works Pieces based on Die Ruinen von Athen

Contents

 [hide] 

Performances

Recordings

 Overture (EU)
#746313 - 11.34MB - 4:57 -  0/10 2 4 6 8 10 (0) - 372×⇩ - MP3 - Lucas-coelho

MP3 file (audio)
Lucas-coelho (2021/11/21)

Performer Pages Orquestra Sinfônica Municipal de São Paulo (orchestra)
Camargo Guarnieri (conductor)
Publisher Info. Concertos Matinais, Vol.3
Mercedes-Benz, 1963.
Copyright
Public Domain - Non-PD US 
Misc. Notes Source: Instituto Piano Brasileiro
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
TN-PMLP1088432-1 LPs Concertos Matinais (1963) Carlos Gomes - Colombo-7995.png

 Overture
4. Marcia alla turca. Vivace (EU)
#563784 - 16.56MB - 7:14 -  0/10 2 4 6 8 10 (0) - 1488×⇩ - MP3 - Vangi

MP3 file (audio)
Vangi (2019/3/5)

Performer Pages Joseph Keilberth (conductor)
Philharmonisches Staatsorchester Hamburg (orchestra)
Bamberger Symphoniker (orchestra)
Publisher Info. Telefunken, 1961.
Copyright
Public Domain - Non-PD US 
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
Contenu neutre.jpg

 4. Marcia alla turca. Vivace (EU)
#570902 - 3.85MB - 1:41 -  7.3333333333333/10 2 4 6 8 10 (3) - 1133×⇩ - MP3 - Vangi

MP3 file (audio)
Vangi (2019/5/3)

Publisher Info. “Trésors de la Musique” - enregistrement original, 1961.
Performers National Symphony, Charles Gerhardt (conductor)
Copyright
Public Domain - Non-PD US 
Misc. Notes Collection personnelle
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
Vignette Beethoven L. van, Concerto p. piano & orch n° 5, op. 73.jpg

Naxos

Synthesized/MIDI

Marcia alla turca (No.4)

For Wind Band (Rondeau)

 Virtual Performance (T.M.)
#179058 - 1.53MB - 1:40 -  8/10 2 4 6 8 10 (5) - 2515×⇩ - MP3 - Michrond

MP3 file (audio)
Michrond (2012/2/15)

Publisher Info. Michel Rondeau
Performers MIDI
Copyright
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 
Misc. Notes These file(s) are part of the Werner Icking Music Collection.
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.

Sheet Music

Scores

Complete

Editor First edition
Publisher. Info. Vienna: Artaria, n.d.[1812]. Plate 3163.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
Publisher. Info. Ludwig van Beethovens Werke, Serie 20, Nr.207
Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d.[1864]. Plate B.207.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes 150dpi grayscale images (file #74006)
Original images: 300dpi, grayscale djvu files approx. 2900 by 3780 pixels. Editing: re-sampled to 600dpi, converted to black and white tif files, de-skewed, and set uniform margins. (file #316311)
Purchase
Publisher. Info. Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d. Plate PB 694.
Reprinted Boca Raton: Edwin F. Kalmus, n.d.(1987-2018). Catalog A1272.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Full Score is 10 x 13 scan.
Purchase

Overture

Editor First edition
Publisher. Info. Vienna: S.A. Steiner & Co., n.d.[1816]. Plate S:u:C: 3951.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
Publisher. Info. Ludwig van Beethovens Werke, Serie 3, Nr.28
Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d.[1864]. Plate B.28.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
Editor Alfred Dörffel (1821-1905)
Publisher. Info. Berühmte Ouverturen von Mozart, Beethoven, Weber, Cherubini
Leipzig: C.F. Peters, n.d.(ca.1880). Plate 5573.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
Purchase
Publisher. Info. London: E. Donajowski, n.d.(ca.1894). Plate E. 4082 D.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
Purchase

 Complete Score
#410369 - 0.35MB, 36 pp. -  0/10 2 4 6 8 10 (0) - !N/!N/!N - 1190×⇩ - Luukas

PDF typeset by editor
Luukas (2016/2/8)

Editor Luukas Hiltunen
Publisher. Info. Luukas Hiltunen
Copyright
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
Misc. Notes Source: Ludwig van Beethovens Werke, Serie 3. Ouverturen für Orchester, Nr.28
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.

Marcia alla turca (No.4)

Publisher. Info. Ludwig van Beethovens Werke, Serie 20, Nr.207
Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d.[1864]. Plate B.207.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase

March with Chorus: Schmückt die Altare, Op.114 (later edition of No.6 with added text and choral parts)

Editor First edition (with holograph corrections)
Publisher. Info. Vienna: S.A. Steiner & Co., n.d.[1826]. Plate S:u:C: 3955.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Includes holograph corrections plus minor text change for 1822 Vienna production.
Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin (D-B): Mus.ms.autogr. Beethoven, L. v., Artaria 161 (1)
Purchase
Editor First edition (revised reprint)
Publisher. Info. Vienna: Tobias Haslinger, n.d.[1826-42]. Plate S:u:C: 3955.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
Publisher. Info. Ludwig van Beethovens Werke, Serie 20, Nr.207a
Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d.[1864]. Plate B.207a.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes 150dpi grayscale images (file #74007)
Original images: 300dpi, grayscale djvu files approx. 2900 by 3780 pixels. Editing: re-sampled to 600dpi, converted to black and white tif files, de-skewed, and set uniform margins. (file #316445)
Purchase

Parts

Complete

⇒ 8 more: Flute 1, 2 • Clarinet 1, 2 (B♭/C/A) • Horn 1, 2 (G/E♭/B♭/C/F/A) • Trumpet 1, 2 (C/B♭/E♭/D) • Timpani • Violins I • Violins II • Violas

Publisher. Info. Ludwig van Beethovens Werke, Serie 20, Nr.207
Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d.[1864]. Plate B.207.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Incomplete set.
Purchase

⇒ 12 more: Oboe 1, 2 • Clarinet 1, 2 • Bassoon 1, 2 • Horn 1, 2, 3, 4 • Trumpet 1, 2 • Trombone 1, 2, 3 • Timpani • Bass Drum, Cymbals, Triangle • Violins I • Violins II • Violas • Cellos/Basses

Publisher. Info. Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d. Plate OB 853/54.
Reprinted Boca Raton: Edwin F. Kalmus, n.d.(1987-2018). Catalog A1272.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Parts are 10 x 13 scans.
Purchase

Overture

⇒ 11 more: Flute 1, 2 • Oboe 1, 2 • Clarinet 1, 2 (B♭) • Bassoon 1, 2 • Horn 1/2 (D), 3 (G), 4 (G) • Trumpet 1, 2 (C) • Timpani • Violins I • Violins II • Violas • Cellos/Basses

Publisher. Info. Paris: Richault, n.d. Plate 1443 R.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase

⇒ 10 more: Oboe 1, 2 • Clarinet 1, 2 (B♭) • Bassoon 1, 2 • Horn 1, 2 (in G), 3, 4 (in D) • Trumpet 1, 2 (in C) • Timpani • Violins I • Violins II • Violas • Cellos/Basses

Publisher. Info. Leipzig: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d.(ca.1880).
Reprinted New York: Edwin F. Kalmus, n.d.(after 1933).
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes These files are part of the Orchestra Parts Project.
Purchase

 Horn I, II
#633491 - 0.39MB, 2 pp. -  0/10 2 4 6 8 10 (0) - !N/!N/!N - 422×⇩ - Lfm

PDF typeset by editor
Lfm (2020/6/28)

Editor Lukas-Fabian Moser
Publisher. Info. Lukas-Fabian Moser
Copyright
Creative Commons Zero 1.0
Misc. Notes for performing the ouverture with only 2 Horns, then replaces #48882
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.

Marcia alla turca (No.4)

⇒ 11 more: Oboe 1, 2 • Clarinet 1, 2 (B♭) • Bassoon 1, 2, Contrabassoon • Horn 1, 2 (in B♭) • Trumpet 1, 2 (in B♭) • Bass Drum, Triangle • Violins I • Violins II • Violas • Cello • Basses

Publisher. Info. Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel, n.d.(ca.1880).
Reprinted New York: E.F. Kalmus, n.d.(1933–70).
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes These files are part of the Orchestra Parts Project.
Purchase

Vocal Scores

Arranger Ann Mounsey Bartholomew (1811–1891)
Language English
Translator William Bartholomew (1793–1867)
Publisher. Info. London: Ewer & Co., n.d.[1844].
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Royal College of Music Library, London (GB-Lcm): D861/4
Purchase
Arranger Friedrich Wilhelm Grund (1791–1874), piano reduction
Language German
Publisher. Info. Hamburg: Joh. Aug. Böhme, n.d.[1859]. Plate 953.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Robert Heller, adaptation of text
Purchase
Language French
Translator Louis Crevel de Charlemagne (1807–1882), French text
Publisher. Info. Paris: Bureau Centra de la Musique, n.d.[1846]. Plate B.C. 930.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
Language English
Translator Paul England (ca.1863–1932)
Publisher. Info. London: Novello and Co., n.d.(ca.1890). Plate 8273.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
Purchase
Publisher. Info. London: Novello and Co., n.d.(ca.1890). Plate 8273.
Reprinted Boca Raton: Edwin F. Kalmus, n.d.(1987-2018). Catalog A1272.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Vocal Score is 10 x 13 scan.
Purchase

 Complete Score
#942748 - 11.61MB, 80 pp. -  10/10 2 4 6 8 10 (1) - V/V/V - 13×⇩ - Dbmiller

PDF scanned by Unknown
Dbmiller (2024/11/22)

Arranger Richard Strauss (1864–1949), adaptation
Hugo von Hofmannsthal (1874–1929), adaptation
Otto Singer II (1863–1931), piano reduction
Publisher. Info. Berlin: Fürstner, 1925. Plate A. 7783 F.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase

Choral Scores

 Choral Score
#587558 - 1.52MB, 22 pp. -  0/10 2 4 6 8 10 (0) - C/C/C - 77×⇩ - Marchesa

PDF scanned by Paul Marchesano
Marchesa (2019/8/28)

Language German
Publisher. Info. Wiesbaden: Breitkopf und Härtel, n.d.[1968]. Plate 3572.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes choralpartitur, no date on imprint
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.

Arrangements and Transcriptions

Selections (Overture and No.4)

For 2 Pianos (Babcock)
Arranger Gaylon Babcock
Publisher. Info. Gaylon Babcock
Copyright
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
Misc. Notes each part designed to be printed front and back
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.

Overture

For Theatre Orchestra (Anonymous)

 Complete Score and Parts
#575940 - 26.06MB, 35 pp. -  0/10 2 4 6 8 10 (0) - V/V/V - 31×⇩ - Davidlhardie

PDF scanned by Unknown
Davidlhardie (2019/6/5)

Arranger Anonymous
Publisher. Info. Hamburg: Anton J. Benjamin, n.d. Plate A. J. B. 4401. 6565.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Condensed Score (piano), 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets (B♭), 2 bassoons, 4 horns (F), 2 trumpets (B♭), trombone, timpani, strings
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
For 2 Pianos 8 hands (Horn)
Arranger August Horn (1825–1893)
Publisher. Info. Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel, n.d. Plate 18542.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
Purchase
For Piano 4 hands
Arranger Unknown
Publisher. Info. London: T. Boosey & Co, importers, n.d.[1823].
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Royal College of Music Library, London (GB-Lcm): D861/3
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
For Piano 4 hands (Kleinmichel)
Arranger Richard Kleinmichel (1846–1901)
Publisher. Info. Leipzig: C.F. Peters, n.d. Plate 8631.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
Purchase
For Piano 4 hands (Ulrich)
See: Sämtliche Ouverturen
For Piano
Publisher. Info. Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel, n.d.(ca.1860). Plate 10095.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
Purchase
For Piano (Brandts Buys)
Arranger Jan Brandts Buys (1868–1933)
Publisher. Info. Wien: Universal Edition, n.d. Plate U. E. 70.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
For Piano (Ulrich)
See: Sämtliche Ouverturen

Chorus of Dervishes (No.3)

For Violin and Piano (Auer)
Arranger Leopold Auer (1845–1930)
Publisher. Info. New York: Carl Fischer, 1916. Plate 19021-8.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
For Piano (Saint-Saëns)
Arranger Camille Saint-Saëns (1835–1921)
Publisher. Info. Paris: Durand, Schoenewerk & Cie., n.d.[1872]. Plate D. S. & Cie. 2043.
Post-1891 re-issue (plate D. & F.)
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
This file is from the MIT archive project.
Purchase

Marcia alla turca (No.4)

For Wind Band (Rondeau)

 Engraving files (Finale)
#179095 - 1.44MB, ? pp. -  0/10 2 4 6 8 10 (0) - !N/!N/!N - 983×⇩ - Michrond

ZIP typeset by arranger
Michrond (2012/2/15)

Arranger Michel Rondeau
Publisher. Info. Michel Rondeau
Copyright
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0
Misc. Notes These file(s) are part of the Werner Icking Music Collection. project
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
For 2 Violins, Viola and Cello (del Arte)

 Complete Score and Parts
#79204 - 0.55MB, 11 pp. -  0/10 2 4 6 8 10 (0) - !N/!N/!N - 3153×⇩ - arranger

PDF typeset by arranger
arranger (2010/9/19)

Editor Alonso del Arte
Publisher. Info. Alonso del Arte
Copyright
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0
Misc. Notes This arrangement has been tested in actual performance and the parts were sufficient for this purpose. Though it doesn't hurt to have the score available.
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
For Violin and Piano (Auer)

 Complete Score and Violin Part
#85174 - 1.51MB, 9 pp. -  4.6666666666667/10 2 4 6 8 10 (3) - V/V/V - 1991×⇩ - Afp0815

PDF scanned by afp0815
Afp0815 (2010/11/19)

Arranger Leopold Auer (1845–1930)
Publisher. Info. New York: Carl Fischer, No.B 48, 1916. Plate 19020.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Scanned at 600dpi.
Purchase
For Violin and Piano (Seybold)
See: The Classical Violin (No.9)
For 2 Pianos (Thern)
Arranger Károly Thern (1817–1886)
Publisher. Info. New York: G. Schirmer, 1904. Plate 10352.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
Purchase
For Piano (Borovsky)
Arranger Alexander Borovsky (1889-1968)
Publisher. Info. Copenhagen: Wilhelm Hansen, 1947. Plate 24040.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
For Piano (Gobbaerts)
Arranger Louis Gobbaerts (1835-1886)
Publisher. Info. Unidentified Publisher, n.d. Plate Th.Ed.1409.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes Scanned at 600 dpi. Manual cleaning. Simplified arrangement.
Purchase
For Piano (Rubinstein)

 Complete Score
#11203 - 0.14MB, 6 pp. -  5/10 2 4 6 8 10 (17) - V/V/C - 5842×⇩ - Guifre

PDF scanned by Unknown
Guifre (2007/8/3)

Arranger Anton Rubinstein (1829–1894)
Editor Sergei Rachmaninoff (1874–1943)
Publisher. Info. Unidentified collection
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is from the MIT archive project.
Rubinstein's original first published - Moscow: P. Jurgenson, n.d.(ca.1868). Plate 506.
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.

 Complete Score
#51018 - 0.27MB, 5 pp. -  8.5384615384615/10 2 4 6 8 10 (13) - 11/V/C - 3687×⇩ - Crimper

PDF scanned by Unknown
Crimper (2009/12/28)

Arranger Anton Rubinstein (1829–1894)
Editor Carl Deis (1883–1960)
Publisher. Info. New York: G. Schirmer, 1917. Plate 27953.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase
Javascript is required for this feature.
For Piano
Publisher. Info. Wien: S.A. Steiner und Comp., n.d.[1823]. Plate S:u:C: 3957.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Gaylord Library Mirroring Project.
Purchase
Arranger Unidentified
Editor Alessandro Longo (1864–1945)
Publisher. Info. Milan: Curci, 1940. Plate E. 2478 C.
Copyright
Public Domain - Non-PD US
Purchase
For Piano 4 Hands (Rubinstein)
Arranger Anton Rubinstein (1829–1894)
Publisher. Info. Moscow: P. Jurgenson, n.d.(ca.1868). Plate 507.
Copyright
Public Domain
Purchase

March with Chorus: Schmückt die Altare (No.6)

For 2 Pianos 8 hands (Burchard)
Arranger Carl Burchard (1818–1896)
Publisher. Info. Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel, n.d. Plate V.A. 1203.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes This file is part of the Sibley Mirroring Project.
Purchase
For Piano (Tedesco)
Arranger Ignaz Tedesco (1817–1882)
Publisher. Info. Breslau: Julius Hainauer, n.d. Plate J. 161 H.
Copyright
Public Domain
Misc. Notes "Marche des Ruines d'Athènes de Beethoven" (No.4) from Souvenir des grands maîtres allemands, 7 transcriptions pour le piano, Op.112
This file is part of the Gaylord Library Mirroring Project.
Purchase

General Information

Work Title Die Ruinen von Athen
Alternative. Title The Ruins of Athens
Name Translations 雅典的废墟; 雅典的廢墟; アテネの廃墟; Τα ερείπια των Αθηνών; Les Ruines d'Athènes; [9 more...]Les ruïnes d'Atenes; Athens ruiner; Ruiny Aten; As Ruínas de Atenas; 아테네의 폐허; La Ruinoj de Ateno; Le rovine di Atene; এথেন্সের ধ্বংসাবশেষ; خرابه‌های آتن
Name Aliases Les Ruïnes d’Atenes de Beethoven; Les Ruïnes d'Atenes de Beethoven
Authorities Wikipedia; BNF: 139081350
Composer Beethoven, Ludwig van
Opus/Catalogue NumberOp./Cat. No. Op.113 (and 114)
Internal Reference NumberInternal Ref. No. ILB 225
Key see below
Movements/SectionsMov'ts/Sec's 9 sections (including overture):
Overture. Andante con moto, (G minor) - Allegro, ma non troppo (G major)
1. Chor. Andante poco sostenuto (E♭ major)
2. Duett. Andante con moto - Poco piu mosso, (G minor)
3. Chor. Allegro ma non troppo (G major)
4. Marcia alla turca. Vivace (B♭ major)
5. Musick hinter der Scene. Allegro assai ma non troppo (C major)
6. Marsch und chor. Assai moderato (E♭ major), later published with additional text and choral parts as Op.114
6a. Recitativo. Vivace (G major)
7a. Chor. Allegretto ma non troppo (G major)
7b. Aria mit Chor. Adagio - Allegro con brio (C major)
8. Chor. Allegro con fuoco (A major)
Text Incipit see below
1. Tochter des mächtigen Zeus
2. Ohne Verschulden Knechtschaft dulden
3. Du hast in deines Ärmels Falten
6. Schmückt die Altare
6a. Mit reger Freude
7a. Wir tragen empfängliche Herzen im Busen
7b.Will unser Genius noch einen Wunsch gewähren?
Er ist's! Wir sind erhört!
8. Heil unserm König!
Year/Date of CompositionY/D of Comp. 1811 (and 1822)
First Performance. 1812-02-9 in Pest, Pest Theater (original version)
1822 in Vienna. Theater in der Josefstadt (revision)
First Publication. 1816 - Artaria
Librettist August von Kotzebue (1761–1819)
Language German
Average DurationAvg. Duration 60 minutes
Composer Time PeriodComp. Period Classical
Piece Style Classical
Instrumentation voices, chorus, orchestra, ballet
InstrDetail [more...]
Cast
Minerva (spoken)
Merkur (spoken)
Ein Grechin (soprano)
Ein Greche (bass)
Das Mädchen (spoken)
Ein Turke (spoken)
Oberpriester (bass)

Mixed Chorus (SATB)
Orchestra

piccolo, 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, contrabassoon
4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani, triangle, cymbals, bass drum, strings
Related Works Pieces based on Die Ruinen von Athen
External Links Wikipedia article
All Music Guide
The Lied, Art Song, and Choral Texts Archive
Extra Information Op. 114 is NOT identical to Op. 113, No. 6. Op. 114 adds text (beginning with "Empfanget uns!") to what had been a purely instrumental closing section in Op. 113, No. 6. The revision with added text (Op. 114) is connected to the recycling of music from Op. 113 for Die Weihe des Hauses (which produced entirely new music, Op. 124 and WoO 98). The edition of Op. 114, No. 207a in the Breitkopf Complete Works Edition, contains the added text, while Op. 113, No. 6 in Breitkopf Complete Works No. 207 does not.

Navigation etc.

[hide]Overtures by Ludwig van Beethoven
Retrieved from "http://imslp.org/index.php?title=Die_Ruinen_von_Athen,_Op.113_(Beethoven,_Ludwig_van)&oldid=4356656"