Beethoven: String Quartet No.11, Op.95

Introduction

Ludwig van Beethoven's String Quartet No. 11 in F minor, Op. 95, is his last before his late string quartets. It is commonly referred to as the "Serioso," stemming from his title "Quartett[o] Serioso" at the beginning and the tempo designation for the third movement.

It is one of the shortest and most compact of all the Beethoven quartets, and shares a tonality (F) with the first and last quartets Beethoven published (Op. 18, no. 1, and Op. 135). In character and key, as well as in the presence of a final frenetic section in the parallel major, it is related to another composition of Beethoven's middle period — the overture to his incidental music for Goethe's drama Egmont, which he was composing in the same year he was working on this quartet.

The autograph manuscript for this quartet is inscribed "October 1810", but the paper on which it appears does not match the variety Beethoven is known to have used at that time. It is more likely that he finished it several months later. It premiered in 1814 and appeared in print two years later, dedicated to Nikolaus Zmeskall. Beethoven stated in a letter to George Smart that "The Quartet [Op. 95] is written for a small circle of connoisseurs and is never to be performed in public." Upon listening to the piece, it becomes apparent why he made that assertion. This piece would have been quite out of character in 1810: it is an experiment on compositional techniques the composer would draw on later in his life. (Techniques such as shorter developments, interesting use of silences, metric ambiguity, seemingly unrelated outbursts, and more freedom with tonality in his sonata form.)

The historical picture of this time period helps to put the piece in context. Napoleon had invaded Vienna earlier that year, and this upset Beethoven greatly. All of his aristocratic friends had fled Vienna, but Beethoven stayed and dramatically complained about the loud bombings.

Form

The quartet is in four movements:

I. Allegro con brio

This movement is in sonata form.

Exposition (mm. 1–59)

1st tonal area, F minor (mm. 1–21): Neapolitan (G♭ chord) important (m. 6, 19); the Neapolitan appears in root position, not its normal first inversion, and the large-scale tritone motion of the bass voice (from G♭ in m.6 to C in m.10) again emphasizes the strident nature of this movement. It ends on a half cadence on the downbeat of measure 21.

Transition (m. 21–23): The unison C on the downbeat of measure 21 (V of F minor) is reinterpreted immediately as the leading tone to the second tonal area, D♭ major. A very short transitional phrase solidifies the move to D♭ major.

2nd tonal area, D♭ major (mm. 24–57): This is signified by a two-measure-long lyrical melody first stated in the viola, then passing through the cello and second violin, then cello again. A long V of D♭ (mm. 32–37) is unexpectedly resolved to A major, which is simply a deceptive V-♭VI cadence (♭VI of D♭ major would be B, here enharmonically respelled as A). The A-major chord is also V of the Neapolitan (♭II in D♭ major would be E, enharmonically respelled as D). This V-I motion of the Neapolitan is explicitly stated by the quartet in unison in measure 39. Measures 40–43 return to the lyrical nature of the second theme and solidify D♭ major. A modified counterstatement of this entire gesture occurs, landing us on an even more explicit use of the Neapolitan, again enharmonically respelled as D♮, in measures 49–50.

Closing (mm. 58–59): There is no repeat of this already very short exposition, which adds to the startling nature of this piece as a whole.

Development (mm. 60–81)

F major	C minor	C Major
m. 60	?	m. 77

The expected dominant pedal occurs beginning in m. 77, but the C prolongation is in the first violin.

Recapitulation (mm. 82–128)

The 1st theme is shorter this time (4 measures is all).

The three-measure transitional phrase reappears (mm. 86–88) but is not recomposed as would be expected. We are again taken to D♭ major.

The 2nd theme begins in D♭ major again (it does not need to be in the primary key like one would ordinarily expect in the recap because the second theme is not in the dominant or relative major). However, it does occur in the tonic major (F major) beginning in measure 93. The move to a D-major chord in measure 107 corresponds to the similar passage in measure 49, but here the D-major chord functions as a V/ii, which initiates a circle-of-fifths progression (D–G–C–F), arriving on F in measure 112.

Coda (mm. 129–end)

Begins in ♭VI (D♭ major): Primary scalar motive of the beginning is developed. This coda is shorter than one might expect considering the already short development.

As Arnold Schoenberg notes in an essay reprinted in the collection Style and Idea, most of the themes and events of this movement – and the main theme of the second movement – contain some form of the motive D♭–C–D–E found in the second bar, even if transposed and changed in some way.

II. Allegretto ma non troppo

This movement is in D major, a startling and remote key from the F-minor first movement. The form is AB | BA.

A (mm. 1–34)

B (mm. 35–64): Fugato section. It eventually falls apart.

|: The descending scalar cello leads through ever modulating tonalities starting a tritone away from the opening scale.

B' (mm. 77–112)

A' (mm. 112–183): The melody is now an octave higher

III. Allegro assai vivace ma serioso

This movement is in scherzo form, as typical in the third movement position. Although because of the very odd tempo marking Maynard Solomon warns against calling it a scherzo, preferring the phrase "march-trio."

Scherzo (mm. 1–40, with a repeat)

Trio (mm. 41–102)

Scherzo (mm. 103–144)

Trio (mm. 145–182)

Scherzo (mm. 183–206): This time the tempo increases (Più Allegro)

IV. Larghetto espressivo; Allegretto agitato; Allegro

This is in the sometimes misunderstood sonata rondo form. In a sonata-rondo, the piece follows the thematic outline of a rondo (ABACABA), and the tonal outline of a sonata (I V I or i III i, etc.). Beethoven uses Mozart's favorite rondo form for this movement (ABACBA). The absence of the A theme in between the C and second B is a surprise and adds interest by reducing the repetition of the A theme.

Intro, F minor (mm. 1–9) (Larghetto expressivo)

A, F minor (mm. 10–32) (Allegretto agitato): It might be prudent to note that the "missing A" from the typical rondo-sonata form could be analyzed as being shifted from its "rightful" place after "C" to a more intriguing place in m. 23.

B, C minor (mm. 32–50)

A', F minor (mm. 51–64)

C (mm. 65–82)

B' (mm. 82–97): Here's where the sonata part of sonata-rondo comes in. This time it's in F minor instead of C minor.

A', F minor (mm. 98–132)

Coda, F major (mm. 133–175) (Allegro): The light and bouncy ending is in sharp contrast to the dark, stormy, introspective mood of the rest of the quartet. Of this, Basil Lam said: this "comic-opera ending, [is] absurdly and deliberately unrelated to the 'quartett serioso' – the true Shakespearean touch that provides the final confirmation of the truth of the rest."^{[citation needed]}

Arrangements

Gustav Mahler arranged this quartet for string orchestra, mostly by doubling some of the cello parts with double basses.